HKB

← back

Politics: A Treatise on Government

Aristotle · c. 335–322 BCE primary

passage 134 of 193 · BOOK I > CHAPTER X (4/4)

↪ you wandered here via “centralized government vs monarchies” — the connecting lines are tinted below

in brief
He states kingdoms are usually not destroyed by outside attacks but by internal causes: leaders inciting sedition or trying to establish tyranny beyond the law, especially in hereditary monarchies.

assigned as the destruction of a pure oligarchy unmixed with any other government and an extreme democracy, the same may be applied to a tyranny; for these are divided tyrannies.

Kingdoms are seldom destroyed by any outward attack; for which reason they are generally very stable; but they have many causes of subversion within; of which two are the principal; one is when those who are in power [1313a] excite a sedition, the other when they endeavour to establish a tyranny by assuming greater power than the law gives them. A kingdom, indeed, is not what we ever see erected in our times, but rather monarchies and tyrannies; for a kingly government is one that is voluntarily submitted to, and its supreme power admitted upon great occasions: but where many are equal, and there are none in any respect so much better than another as to be qualified for the greatness and dignity of government over them, then these equals will not willingly submit to be commanded; but if any one assumes the government, either by force or fraud, this is a tyranny. To what we have already said we shall add, the causes of revolutions in an hereditary kingdom. One of these is, that many of those who enjoy it are naturally proper objects of contempt only: another is, that they are insolent while their power is not despotic; but they possess kingly honours only. Such a state is soon destroyed; for a king exists but while the people are willing to obey, as their submission to him is voluntary, but to a tyrant involuntary. These and such-like are the causes of the destruction of monarchies.

← previous passage read in the full work → next passage →

topics: civil war and rebellion · faction, party, and civil strife · revolution and the fall of states · tyranny and despotism

Politics: A Treatise on Government · Aristotle · 335–322 BCE