HKB

← back

An Essay Concerning Humane Understanding, Volume 2

John Locke · 1690 (2nd volume in Essay Concerning Human Understanding) primary

passage 217 of 237 · BOOK III. OF WORDS. > CHAPTER XVII. OF REASON (7/10)

↪ you wandered here via “use of reason for knowledge” — the connecting lines are tinted below

in brief
Locke argues syllogism cannot discover new proofs or increase knowledge, only fences with what is already possessed, comparing the process to forging iron into swords for pointless sparring.
  1. Our highest Degree of Knowledge is intuitive, without Reasoning.

Some of the ideas that are in the mind, are so there, that they can be by themselves immediately compared one with another: and in these the mind is able to perceive that they agree or disagree as clearly as that it has them. Thus the mind perceives, that an arch of a circle is less than the whole circle, as clearly as it does the idea of a circle: and this, therefore, as has been said, I call INTUITIVE KNOWLEDGE; which is certain, beyond all doubt, and needs no probation, nor can have any; this being the highest of all human certainty. In this consists the evidence of all those MAXIMS which nobody has any doubt about, but every man (does not, as is said, only assent to, but) KNOWS to be true, as soon as ever they are proposed to his understanding. In the discovery of and assent to these truths, there is no use of the discursive faculty, NO NEED OF REASONING, but they are known by a superior and higher degree of evidence. And such, if I may guess at things unknown, I am apt to think that angels have now, and the spirits of just men made perfect shall have, in a future state, of thousands of things which now either wholly escape our apprehensions, or which our short-sighted reason having got some faint glimpse of, we, in the dark, grope after.

  1. The next is got by Reasoning.

But though we have, here and there, a little of this clear light, some sparks of bright knowledge, yet the greatest part of our ideas are such, that we cannot discern their agreement or disagreement by an immediate comparing them. And in all these we have NEED OF REASONING, and must, by discourse and inference, make our discoveries. Now of these there are two sorts, which I shall take the liberty to mention here again:--

First, through Reasonings that are Demonstrative.

← previous passage read in the full work → next passage →

topics: doubt, skepticism, and certainty · logic, method, and demonstration · reason and the intellect

An Essay Concerning Humane Understanding, Volume 2 · John Locke · 1690