HKB

← back

Considerations on Representative Government

John Stuart Mill · 1840s–1861 (composition and revision; see publication date omitted)

passage 19 of 187 · Chapter I--To What Extent Forms of Government are a Matter of Choice. > Chapter II--The Criterion of a Good Form of Government. (10/15)

↪ you wandered here via “administrative science and practice” — the connecting lines are tinted below

in brief
He says many practical rules of law, property, evidence, taxation, and finance can be beneficial across forms of government, but institutions must differ radically for training people according to their stage of development.

by which political institutions improve or deteriorate the human mind, and the causes and modes of that beneficial or injurious influence remain a distinct and much wider subject of study.

Of the two modes of operation by which a form of government or set of political institutions affects the welfare of the community--its operation as an agency of national education, and its arrangements for conducting the collective affairs of the community in the state of education in which they already are, the last evidently varies much less, from difference of country and state of civilization, than the first. It has also much less to do with the fundamental constitution of the government. The mode of conducting the practical business of government, which is best under a free constitution, would generally be best also in an absolute monarchy, only an absolute monarchy is not so likely to practice it. The laws of property, for example; the principles of evidence and judicial procedure; the system of taxation and of financial administration, need not necessarily be different in different forms of government. Each of these matters has principles and rules of its own, which are a subject of separate study. General jurisprudence, civil and penal legislation, financial and commercial policy, are sciences in themselves, or, rather, separate members of the comprehensive science or art of government; and the most enlightened doctrines on all these subjects, though not equally likely to be understood and acted on under all forms of government, yet, if understood and acted on, would in general be equally beneficial under them all. It is true that these doctrines could not be applied without some modifications to all states of society and of the human mind; nevertheless, by far the greater number of them would require modifications solely of detail to adapt them to any state of society sufficiently advanced to possess rulers capable of understanding them. A government to which they would be wholly unsuitable must be one so bad in itself, or so opposed to public feeling, as to be unable to maintain itself in existence by honest means.

← previous passage read in the full work → next passage →

topics: custom and unwritten law · education and the training of the young · property, inheritance, and title

Considerations on Representative Government · John Stuart Mill · 1840–1861