Alexandria

← back

A Treatise on Relics

Jean Calvin (with introductory dissertation by Valerian Krasinski) · 1543 primary

passage 71 of 138 · Chapter I. Origin Of The Worship Of Relics And Images In The Christian > Chapter VIII. Image-Worship And Other Superstitious Practices Of The (4/52)

↪ you wandered here via “Anglican holy communion practice” — the connecting lines are tinted below

in brief
Calvin’s editor/annotator contrasts the Greek-Russian and Roman Catholic Churches, explaining disagreements over church headship (Pope, Patriarch, or Czar) and arguing that union of Florence leaves sacraments “valid” but requires rebaptism for converts into each other’s churches.

the movement alluded to above, which has recently begun to spread amongst the Armenian churches of Turkey, was not without influence on the mission of Prince Menschikoff and its consequences.

I have said above that the mutual position of the Græco-Russian and Roman Catholic Churches towards one another is that of two rivals. The dogmatic difference between them turns upon some abstruse tenets, which are generally little understood by the great mass of their followers, whilst the essential ground of divergence, the real question at issue, is, whether the headship of the church is to be vested in the Pope, in the Patriarch of Constantinople, or in the Czar. The Pope has allowed that portion of the Greek Church which submitted to his supremacy at the council of Florence in 1438, to retain its ritual and discipline, with some insignificant modifications. The Roman Catholic Church considers the Græco-Russian one in about the same light as she is regarded herself by that of England. She acknowledges her to be a church, though a schismatic one, whose sacraments and ordination are valid, so that a Greek or Russian priest becomes, on signing the union of Florence, a clergyman of the Roman Catholic Church exactly as is the case in the Anglican Church with a Roman Catholic priest who renounces the pope. The Græco-Russian Church does not, however, return the compliment to the Roman Catholic one, any more than the Catholic does it to that of England; because a Roman Catholic priest who enters the Græco-Russian Church not only loses his sacerdotal character, just as is the case with an Anglican clergyman who goes over to the communion of Rome, but he must be even baptised anew, as is done with Christians of every denomination who join that church, whether Jews or Gentiles.

← previous passage read in the full work → next passage →

topics: contracts, oaths, and obligation · counsel and advisers to rulers · forms of government

A Treatise on Relics · Jean Calvin (with introductory dissertation by Valerian Krasinski) · 1543