ProjectAlexandria

← back

An Old Babylonian Version of the Gilgamesh Epic

Morris Jastrow Jr. & Albert T. Clay · Old Babylonian Version of the Gilgamesh Epic (study based on earlier cuneiform tablets)

passage 25 of 71 · Part III > i.e., again the hero *par excellence*, the original hero, just as in (12/28)

↪ you wandered here via “Biblical account sun stood still” — the connecting lines are tinted below

in brief
The authors contrast optimistic Babylonian lessons with the Biblical writer’s pessimistic view, argue that Enkidu’s episode proved it could be detached from Gilgamesh, and describe further moral/cultural instruction.

of pastoral life. This aspect of the incident is, therefore, to be separated from the other phase which has as its chief motif the bringing of the two heroes together.

We now obtain, thanks to the new section revealed by the Pennsylvania tablet, a further analogy [107] with the story of Adam and Eve, but with this striking difference, that whereas in the Babylonian tale the woman is the medium leading man to the higher life, in the Biblical story the woman is the tempter who brings misfortune to man. This contrast is, however, not inherent in the Biblical story, but due to the point of view of the Biblical writer, who is somewhat pessimistically inclined and looks upon primitive life, when man went naked and lived in a garden, eating of fruits that grew of themselves, as the blessed life in contrast to advanced culture which leads to agriculture and necessitates hard work as the means of securing one's substance. Hence the woman through whom Adam eats of the tree of knowledge and becomes conscious of being naked is looked upon as an evil tempter, entailing the loss of the primeval life of bliss in a gorgeous Paradise. The Babylonian point of view is optimistic. The change to civilized life--involving the wearing of clothes and the eating of food that is cultivated (bread and wine) is looked upon as an advance. Hence the woman is viewed as the medium of raising man to a higher level. The feature common to the Biblical and Babylonian tales is the attachment of a lesson to early folk-tales. The story of Adam and Eve, [108] as the story of Enkidu and the woman, is told with a purpose. Starting with early traditions of men's primitive life on earth, that may have arisen independently, Hebrew and Babylonian writers diverged, each group going its own way, each reflecting the particular point of view from which the evolution of human society was viewed.

← previous passage read in the full work → next passage →

topics: custom and the manners of a people · justice as a virtue · the problem of evil and theodicy

An Old Babylonian Version of the Gilgamesh Epic · Morris Jastrow Jr. & Albert T. Clay · 1920