HKB

← back

Considerations on Representative Government

John Stuart Mill · 1840s–1861 (composition and revision; see publication date omitted)

passage 38 of 187 · Chapter I--To What Extent Forms of Government are a Matter of Choice. > Chapter IV--Under what Social Conditions Representative Government is Inapplicable. (1/8)

in brief
Mill turns to when representative government becomes inapplicable, listing three foundational requirements: the people’s willingness to accept it, to preserve it, and to perform its imposed duties.

We have recognized in representative government the ideal type of the most perfect polity for which, in consequence, any portion of mankind are better adapted in proportion to their degree of general improvement. As they range lower and lower in development, that form of government will be, generally speaking, less suitable to them, though this is not true universally; for the adaptation of a people to representative government does not depend so much upon the place they occupy in the general scale of humanity as upon the degree in which they possess certain special requisites; requisites, however, so closely connected with their degree of general advancement, that any variation between the two is rather the exception than the rule. Let us examine at what point in the descending series representative government ceases altogether to be admissible, either through its own unfitness or the superior fitness of some other regimen.

First, then, representative, like any other government, must be unsuitable in any case in which it can not permanently subsist--i.e., in which it does not fulfill the three fundamental conditions enumerated in the first chapter. These were, 1. That the people should be willing to receive it. 2. That they should be willing and able to do what is necessary for its preservation. 3. That they should be willing and able to fulfill the duties and discharge the functions which it imposes on them.

← previous passage read in the full work → next passage →

topics: adultery, divorce, and separation · forms of government · political legitimacy and consent

Considerations on Representative Government · John Stuart Mill · 1840–1861